What's Behind the Mortgage Acceleration Phenomenon? Math, Science, Or Science Fiction?

One of the most controversial subjects to hit thethese mortgage acceleration software programs work
information highway in the last few years is theis the volume of protests from those who work on the
development of equity accelerator programs or theother side of the balance sheet.
use of software to facilitate an early mortgage payoff.If you look at how these programs work, it becomes
It seems that everyone has an opinion about theseclear that it's not voodoo, magic, or part of the financial
new mortgage principal reduction programs as tobail out plan. It's just our money paying off our debt.
whether they are a mathematically legitimate andCould we accomplish the same thing ourselves?
viable method of accelerating the payoff of mortgagePossibly so, however, most of us don't.
and other debt.The concept of mortgage acceleration is only part
The proponents of the mortgage acceleratormathematical. The balance of the concept is more
programs claim that they will enable homeowners tobehavioral in nature.
pay off their existing mortgage in a fraction of theWe all know that, in order to lose weight, we need to
normal time by utilizing mathematical formulas orstop eating so much and exercise more. Yet there is a
algorithms which direct cash flow and discretionarybillion dollar weight loss industry that is thriving despite
income to offset the principle and interest associatedthis physiological fact.
with conventional mortgage amortization.Perhaps the key to mortgage acceleration software
Yet the math they are able to demonstrate can beprograms is that they show us how to make better
found in a common mortgage amortization calculator.financial decisions. Take the concept of virtual interest,
The opponents contend these programs do nothingfor example. If we have a mortgage, we pay virtual
that one can't accomplish on their own and that theinterest on everything that we buy. The $5 we spent
cost is, therefore, unjustified.at Starbucks this morning could have been sent to pay
The most critical commentary seems to come fromdown the principle on our mortgage. Rather, we chose
individuals in the mortgage industry. Are they speakingnot to do that and so will pay virtual interest on that $5
from a sense of altruism or is their vehementlyfor the next 20 or 30 years. To our balance sheet,
negative position an inadvertent testament to thethere is no difference between virtual and actual
effectiveness of mortgage acceleration analysisinterest.
software?Had we known that the true cost of that cup of
Still more albeit less aggressive criticism comes fromcoffee was $30; would we still have bought it? These
the professional ranks of financial advisors. It is moreprograms put our normal cash flow into a format that
of a conceptual argument that one should direct theirdemonstrates the effect of our discretionary spending
financial resources into investment strategies ratherand forces us to make better buying decisions. They
than toward mortgage reduction strategies.reinforce the good decisions by giving us positive, goal
If you are able to earn an 8% return, it would makeoriented feedback. They negatively reinforce the bad
mathematical sense to grow that account rather thandecisions by visibly adding time to our sentence of
pay off debt at 6%, but does the arbitrage argumentdebt.
assume a higher rate of return on the investment thanHad we all been given a proper financial education,
were likely to see these days? Also, is arbitrage, thethen we wouldn't need mortgage reduction programs
process of investing borrowed money, something thatand the points made on either side of the issue would
the average American family should feel comfortablebe moot. Instead, we were taught chemistry and
in doing in a volatile market?algebra and so, the controversy will continue.
So, all that one may need in the way of validation that